Short answer
Yes, against one dangerous Humanoid with a weak Wisdom save. Hold Person makes a visible Humanoid within 60 feet roll a Wisdom save or become Paralyzed, and it repeats the save at the end of each of its turns. At a spell save DC of 15 against a +2 save bonus, the target fails the first save 60% of the time and stays held through a second turn 36% of the time.
What does the 2024 Hold Person spell do?
The System Reference Document 5.2 lists Hold Person as a level 2 Enchantment with an Action casting time, a range of 60 feet, verbal, somatic and material components (a straight piece of iron) and a duration of Concentration, up to 1 minute.
"At the end of each of its turns, the target repeats the save, ending the spell on itself on a success. ... You can target one additional Humanoid for each spell slot level above 2."
Source: System Reference Document 5.2, Wizards of the Coast LLC, CC-BY-4.0 (key lines). You choose a Humanoid you can see within range, and the target makes a Wisdom saving throw. On a failure it has the Paralyzed condition for the duration.
The repeat save is what makes the spell swingy. A target that fails once is not held for the full minute: each of its turns it gets another chance to shake the spell off.
What changed from 2014 to 2024?
| Detail | 2014 (SRD 5.1) | 2024 (SRD 5.2) |
|---|---|---|
| Target | A humanoid you can see within 60 feet | A Humanoid you can see within 60 feet |
| Save | Wisdom save, repeated at the end of each of its turns | Same |
| Effect | Paralyzed for the duration | Has the Paralyzed condition for the duration |
| Material component | A small, straight piece of iron | A straight piece of iron |
| Extra targets | One more humanoid per slot level above 2, all within 30 feet of each other | One more Humanoid per slot level above 2; no distance limit in the text we checked |
| Duration | Concentration, up to 1 minute | Same |
Nothing that moves the odds changed. The save, the repeat save and the one-minute Concentration limit all match, so the table in the next section holds for both versions of the spell. Only the extra-target clause reads differently, which matters if you plan to upcast onto a spread-out group.
How many rounds does the target stay paralyzed?
A creature succeeds on a save if its d20 roll plus its Wisdom save bonus meets your spell save DC. There is no automatic success or failure on a roll of 1 or 20 for saving throws, so each possible d20 result counts the same. The chance it fails is (DC minus its bonus minus 1) divided by 20, and the same chance applies at each repeat save. The table shows three numbers per cell: the chance it fails the first save and loses its next turn, the chance it is also still held after a second turn, and the chance it is still held after a third turn (so held three or more turns).
| Target Wisdom save bonus | Your DC 13 | Your DC 15 | Your DC 17 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 turn, 2 turns, 3+ turns | 1 turn, 2 turns, 3+ turns | 1 turn, 2 turns, 3+ turns | |
| -1 | 65%, 42%, 27% | 75%, 56%, 42% | 85%, 72%, 61% |
| +0 | 60%, 36%, 22% | 70%, 49%, 34% | 80%, 64%, 51% |
| +2 | 50%, 25%, 13% | 60%, 36%, 22% | 70%, 49%, 34% |
| +4 | 40%, 16%, 6% | 50%, 25%, 13% | 60%, 36%, 22% |
| +6 | 30%, 9%, 3% | 40%, 16%, 6% | 50%, 25%, 13% |
| +8 | 20%, 4%, 1% | 30%, 9%, 3% | 40%, 16%, 6% |
Read one cell: with a DC of 15 against a target at +2, the chance it fails the first save is 60%. It is still held after its next repeat save 36% of the time, and after the one after that 22% of the time. A target at +8 is held on a failed first save only 30% of the time, and held for three or more turns in about 3% of casts.
Two rules of thumb come out of the table. First, the spell is strongest on enemies with low Wisdom, such as brutes and soldiers, and weakest on priests, wizards and other high-Wisdom humanoids, where a +6 or +8 bonus puts the odds close to a coin flip. Second, the spell rarely lasts the full minute. Even at 80% fail chance, the target is still held after three turns only about half the time, so cast it when your allies can act on the first round.
What is a held target worth to melee allies?
The Paralyzed condition changes how attacks against the target work. In the 2014 text, attack rolls against a paralyzed creature have advantage and any hit from an attacker within 5 feet is a critical hit. The 2024 entry lists the same two effects, under the headings "Attacks Affected" and "Automatic Critical Hits". For allies standing next to the target, that means advantage on the roll and every hit counts double on the dice.
The table assumes a critical hit rolls the weapon's damage dice twice. The weapon is a d8 plus 4 (average 8.5, or 13 on a critical hit). The Sneak Attack column adds 3d6 (average 10.5) to each hit, so a normal hit averages 19 and a critical hit 34, and it assumes the Rogue meets the Sneak Attack condition in both cases.
| d20 roll needed to hit | d8 + 4 weapon | Same weapon plus 3d6 Sneak Attack | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Normal | Target held | Gain | Normal | Target held | Gain | |
| 5 | 6.8 | 12.5 | x1.8 | 15.2 | 32.6 | x2.1 |
| 8 | 5.5 | 11.4 | x2.1 | 12.3 | 29.8 | x2.4 |
| 11 | 4.3 | 9.8 | x2.3 | 9.5 | 25.5 | x2.7 |
| 14 | 3.0 | 7.5 | x2.5 | 6.6 | 19.6 | x3.0 |
| 17 | 1.7 | 4.7 | x2.8 | 3.8 | 12.2 | x3.2 |
The figures are expected damage per attack. Read one row: an ally who needs an 11 hits half the time normally, for 4.3 damage per swing with the plain weapon. Against a held target the hit chance rises to 75% and every hit is a critical, so the same swing averages 9.8, about 2.3 times as much. With Sneak Attack the multiplier is higher still, because a critical hit doubles a bigger pool of dice.
The gain is biggest when the ally normally misses a lot: needing a 17 turns 2.1 damage into 5.7 for the plain weapon, a 2.7 times gain, and for a Rogue it is about 3.1 times. Allies at range get no critical hit, since the rule needs the attacker within 5 feet, though they still get advantage. Held targets are why Hold Person is a better opener when the party has several melee attackers than when it has archers and casters.
Which classes get Hold Person?
- Bard: a known spell, so it takes one of your limited picks.
- Cleric: prepared from the Cleric list, alongside Bless.
- Druid: prepared like a Cleric.
- Sorcerer: a known spell, with a high casting stat that keeps the DC up.
- Warlock: a known spell, so it takes one of your limited picks.
- Wizard: prepared from the spellbook, usually kept for the right fight.
If a Druid already holds Conjure Animals and the party wants a different Concentration spell, they have to choose, because only one can run at a time. A caster who prefers damage can compare it with Fireball.
Rulings and common mistakes
- Humanoids only. Check the creature type before you spend the slot.
- One Concentration spell at a time. Casting another Concentration spell ends Hold Person.
- The target gets a save every turn. Do not count on the minute.
- Higher slots add targets. One more Humanoid per slot level above 2, each with its own save.
Questions
Does Hold Person work on any creature?
No. The spell targets a Humanoid you can see within range, so check the creature type in the stat block before you cast. Any creature that is not a Humanoid is not a valid target.
How long does Hold Person last?
Up to 1 minute while you keep Concentration, but the target repeats its saving throw at the end of each of its turns and ends the spell on itself with a success. In practice it often lasts one or two rounds.
Can I cast Hold Person on more than one target?
Yes, with a higher-level slot. Each slot level above 2 adds one more Humanoid target. All of them make their own saves.
Is Hold Person better than a damage spell?
It depends on the target's Wisdom save. The table above shows the odds: against a low save bonus the spell is likely to land and hold for a round or two, and against a high save bonus a damage spell is the safer use of the slot.
Corin Ashdown is the pen name of the editor who writes and checks every guide on Vorbelutrioperbir. How we write and check guides.